Capital Punishment
“Capital Punishment is against the better judgement of modern criminology and, above all, against the highest expression of love in the nature of God.”
– Dr Martin Luther King, Jr
“Capital Punishment is as fundamentally wrong as a cure for crime as charity is wrong as a cure for poverty.”
– Henry Ford
Capital punishment has, until the last several decades, been firmly embedded in the justice system of Western civilizations (particularly the United States). However, the consensus regarding its permissibility has gradually shifted toward abolition. This has been in part due to better systems of incarceration, disparities in its implementation drawn along racial and economic lines, and the fact that a single violent crime—while still abhorrent—does not per se pose an existential threat to civilized society. Indeed, even within the Christian tradition there has been a debate about the permissibility of capital punishment which we recognize.1 While we agree that the state has an obligation to mete out serious and proportionate justice to those duly convinced in order to preserve order, apply retribution and protect society, we also believe that capital punishment (the death penalty) is not consistent with the dignity of all human life.
- Whether on issues such as abortion, euthanasia or capital punishment, we hold that a person is invaluable and that his or her value is also immutable—it does not change based on what they did, or might do, or have not done.
- Further, we believe a human person’s value is not subject to change by the wishes of humans and their laws, choices or hard circumstances; but rather a person’s value is transcendent and therefore if he or she has a right to life before a crime, this right to life persists even after. This is consistent with our position against abortion, which also causes the death of a human being.
- Since we believe that killing a human being through abortion undermines human dignity inherent to every human being, it stands to reason that capital punishment does the same, regardless of any capital crime.
As the French philosopher Jacques Maritain articulated in the last century, “A single human soul is worth more than the whole universe of material goods. There is nothing higher than the immoral soul, save God. With respect to the eternal destiny of the soul, society exists for each person and is subordinated to it.”2 Thus, the State has no inherent right to forfeit the right to life of a single individual in order to obtain some other good—including the goods of security, retributive justice, or “law and order.” To do so places some other good higher than the good of the human person.
A just society begins with a recognition that society exists for the person, not the other way around. This principle is best described by the Equal Justice Initiative, which states that “the question we need to ask about the death penalty in America is not whether someone deserves to die for a crime. The question is whether we deserve to kill.”3
Of specific note is that in all executions today a healthcare professional is required either to administer a lethal injection “humanely” and/or to verify the death of an executed person. We believe, consistent with our positions on abortion and euthanasia, that physicians, pharmacists, medical researchers and other healthcare professionals should not be involved in the killing of any innocent person, nor use the justification that “it is at least being done humanely.” Indeed, the Hippocratic Oath itself states that “I will give no deadly medicine to any one if asked, nor suggest any such counsel.”4 In short, we believe that physicians and other healthcare professionals that participate in the death penalty undermine the purpose of the medicine itself and violate the trust between doctor and patient.
In the heart of every person is a desire to “do good and avoid evil.”5 We do not believe that any person is intrinsically evil. Yet, we also recognize that in performing evil acts, justice demands punishment (such as incarceration) for certain justly convicted individuals for reasons such as safety, proportionate retribution, and deterrence. Even in these cases, we demand that prisoners be treated with the dignity and respect that is owed them as human persons, and therefore, even for capital crimes, will advocate for humane conditions in our prisons that give a person every opportunity for contrition, repentance, and ultimately, redemption. Capital punishment deprives the convicted person of all of those things which undermines respect for persons in a just society. While we therefore do not oppose just punishment for crimes—proportionate to the seriousness of the offense—Right to Life of Northeast Ohio opposes the death penalty in all cases without exception – regardless of who is accused, the nature or circumstances of the crime, guilt or innocence, or method of execution.
1 https://www.prisonfellowship.org/resources/advocacy/sentencing/the-death-penalty/
2 https://maritain.nd.edu/jmc/etxt/CG04.htm
3 https://eji.org/issues/death-penalty/
4 https://www.britanica.com/topic/Hippocratic-oath
5 St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica 1-2, O94
Links
- Amnesty International
- Equal Justice Institute Dr. Martin Luther King’s Moral Opposition to the Death Penalty
- United Nations Human Rights Council
- WMA Resolution on Prohibition of Physician Participation in Capital Punishment
- American Medical Association Code of Ethics on Capital Punishment
- Advocates For Human Rights
- Scientific American: Evidence Does Not Support Use of the Death Penalty
- The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops
- Ohioans to Stop Executions
- Conservatives Concerned About the Death Penalty